All Makeup Skin Hair Nails How-To Beauty Amplified Spoilers IPSY 101 Ingredient Index

I Tried the Tarte™ Fake Awake™ Eye Highlight—It’s Like Instant Beauty Sleep in a Pen

IPSY LogoIPSY Logo
By
Published on Jun 24, 2024
 Mobile Desktop

Confession: My sleep hygiene could probably benefit from an intervention. I feel like I can never get enough sleep. Between juggling a beyond-busy work schedule, maintaining my fitness routine, attempting to live a clutter-free life, and late nights binging YouTube videos on topics ranging from the latest and greatest Costco finds to the hottest beauty tea on IPSY’s Hitting Pan podcast—I don’t know how and when I’m supposed to get anywhere near the recommended seven to nine hours of sleep each night. 

So, when I was asked to review the TARTE™ Fake Awake™ Eye Highlight, I jumped at the chance. Has TARTE™ really created a magical eyeliner that allows you to fake it (beauty sleep) ’til you make it, resulting in a bigger, brighter, wide-awake look? Is this all too good to be true? In the name of beauty science, I put it to the test. Keep reading to find out if this “trick in a stick™” actually delivers game-changing results. 

 Mobile Desktop
Default Middle Subscribe Module Image - MobileDefault Middle Subscribe Module Image - Desktop

It's about glam time you treated yourself.

Join IPSY

What You Need to Know About the Fake Awake™ Eye Highlight

When my TARTE™ Fake Awake™ Eye Highlight arrived, I was very excited. I quickly ripped the package open and inspected the goods. I received the nude color (spoiler alert: you might receive it in your July Glam Bag!), which is designed to neutralize your waterline. After a little research on the brand’s website and trusty TikTok, I learned that you can also use this to brighten the inner corner of your eyes, brow bone, nose bridge, and Cupid’s bow. I was ready to get to work. Luckily, the twist-up pen made applying the waterproof gel eyeliner a breeze, gliding on smoothly and blending easily for flawless coverage. Plus, it’s powered by aloe vera, antioxidants, and none of the bad stuff.

 Mobile Desktop

Let’s Look Alive (AKA My Testing Strategy)

To start, I casually tested out the Fake Awake™ Eye Highlight on only one eye (my left eye in the photo below) and was immediately impressed by the “eye-opening” results. It shockingly made my left eye “pop” and appear bigger and brighter. But, would it last all day, and would I still feel the same about it by the end of the night? I decided to wear this on only one eye throughout the day, and then checked to see how “awake” I still looked by the time I was ready for my nighttime skincare routine.

 Mobile Desktop

To my delight, my left eye (the one with the product on it), still looked significantly bigger, brighter, and “more alive” when compared to my right eye, which was au natural. My left eye still looked the same as when I first applied it in the morning, and removing it was super easy with micellar water or an oil-based cleanser. 

 Mobile Desktop

My second day using it, I applied the Fake Awake™ Eye Highlight along the inner rims and corners of both of my eyes, as well as along my brow bone, the bridge of my nose, and Cupid’s bow. I wore this all day and once again felt a long-lasting surge of glowing confidence when it came to the appearance of my eyes and other facial features. 

 Mobile Desktop

Key Takeaways 

My final verdict: Don’t sleep on the TARTE Fake Awake™ Eye Highlight. The hype is real and it definitely performs. Whether you’re a sleep-deprived insomniac or a well-rested sleeping beauty, anyone and everyone who’s ready for a quick eye boost can benefit from the incredible results. It does what the brand claims, helping you look like you’ve had “eight hours of beauty sleep…for the nights you only got four.” It’s effortless application makes it perfect for both makeup aficionados and makeup newbies (like me). I’ll definitely be adding this as a staple to my morning routine and can’t wait to keep looking “more awake.”

Want in on all the tips, tricks, and top picks to ace your beauty game? Take our Beauty Quiz now to get started with your own IPSY beauty subscription. Already an IPSY member? Refer your friends to earn points, which you can use toward products. Either way, don’t forget to check us out on Instagram and TikTok @IPSY.

Like this article? Share it with your friends by clicking the icons below!

Liked this post? Share!

Related Stories

Makeup

The Best Setting Spray Hacks Every Beauty Lover Needs to Know

Published on Sep 25, 2025 • 5 min read

Actress Gwyneth Paltrow attends the "Shakespeare in Love" Premiere Party on December 3, 1998 at the St Regis Hotel in New York CityActress Gwyneth Paltrow attends the "Shakespeare in Love" Premiere Party on December 3, 1998 at the St Regis Hotel in New York City

Makeup

25 Iconic ‘90s Beauty Trends That We’re Still Obsessed With

Published on Sep 23, 2025 • 10 min read

Close-up of Maddie Aberman applying BENEFIT COSMETICS Fan Fest MascaraClose-up of Maddie Aberman applying BENEFIT COSMETICS Fan Fest Mascara

Makeup

I Tried Benefit’s New Fan Fest Mascara—It’s Like Lash Extensions in a Tube

Published on Aug 12, 2024

Bold pink eyeshadow paired with soft pink lips and statement earrings captures the vibrant, playful essence of 1980s makeupBold pink eyeshadow paired with soft pink lips and statement earrings captures the vibrant, playful essence of 1980s makeup

Makeup

These ’80s-Inspired Makeup Ideas Will Keep You in the Colorful Spirit

Published on Sep 19, 2025 • 9 min read

An image of a person with wavy black hair wears bold red and black vampire-inspired makeup, featuring smudged eyes and a blood-like streak by the lipsAn image of a person with wavy black hair wears bold red and black vampire-inspired makeup, featuring smudged eyes and a blood-like streak by the lips

Makeup

Halloween Makeup Looks In Five Minutes? We’ve Got You Covered

Published on Sep 18, 2025 • 10 min read

A close-up collage of Il Makiage makeup essentials—eyeshadow palette, mascara, blush, and liquid lipstick—set against a soft peach-to-pink gradient backdrop in a chic, fashion-forward backdropA close-up collage of Il Makiage makeup essentials—eyeshadow palette, mascara, blush, and liquid lipstick—set against a soft peach-to-pink gradient backdrop in a chic, fashion-forward backdrop

Makeup

The 10 IL MAKIAGE Products That Leveled Up Our Makeup Look

Published on Sep 16, 2025 • 7 min read

A woman with Halloween makeup look featuring sharp winged eyeliner, splattered red face paint, and black eye accentsA woman with Halloween makeup look featuring sharp winged eyeliner, splattered red face paint, and black eye accents

Makeup

75 Spellbinding Halloween Eye Looks to Try This Year

Published on Sep 16, 2025 • 15 min read

RMS BEAUTY UnCoverup Concealer, WINKY LUX Peeper Perfect Under-Eye Concealer, YENSA BEAUTY Super Serum Silk Concealer, ALLEYOOP Gameface Second Skin ConcealerRMS BEAUTY UnCoverup Concealer, WINKY LUX Peeper Perfect Under-Eye Concealer, YENSA BEAUTY Super Serum Silk Concealer, ALLEYOOP Gameface Second Skin Concealer

Makeup

The 10 Best Under-Eye Concealers to Banish Dark Circles for Good

Published on Sep 16, 2025 • 8 min read

Default Bottom Subscribe Module Imagebottom_subscribe_module_image_desktop

Beauty Picked Just for You

Get 5 products worth up to $70

Plus exclusive access to epic deals up to 80% off

Starting at just $14/month. Cancel anytime.

Get Started